I have one or two complaints. He oversimplied 19th century immigration restrictions. The Oriental Exclusion Acts are oversimplified; the bond requirements for impoverished immigrants in antebellum America. I also am a bit disappointed by the I think false portrayal of America having a realistic chance of doing something to stop the Holocaust.
On the plus side, many individual Americans and officials did great things to save lives. The War Refugee Board played an important part in the work done by Wallenberg and other diplomats in Hungary in saving hundreds of thousands of lives.
There is an obvious message here: we waited too long to engage in stopping the brutality of the aggressor that started the war.
I can see why working on this documentary might have impaired his ability to see the differences between our current situation and 1940.
To his credit, he also shows that the idea of the U.S. stopping the Holocaust by bombing was impractical.
Of course, he has to close with a progression from National Socialists to white supremacists to the Charlottesville riot and then the Jan.6 riot with the obvious implications. Even though the Holocaust was not a small number of rioters fighting a government but a government using its nearly unlimited resources.
Good article from American Spectator about the flaws of the final episode. I would add one more: the Holocaust was not about unhinged thugs murdering innocent people by themselves but the resources of a national government focused on order, much like the concern about Jan. 6.
No comments:
Post a Comment